June 23, 2021


equality opinion

Florida Supreme Court rejects problem to healthcare cannabis legislation

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. – Siding with the state in a intently watched case that has stored the cannabis market in limbo, the Florida Supreme Court on Thursday upheld a 2017 regulation intended to have out a constitutional amendment that broadly legalized professional medical cannabis.

The court’s 42-webpage ruling arrived in a drawn-out legal battle released by Tampa-centered Florigrown LLC, which, in component, challenged the state’s program of necessitating licensed clinical-marijuana operators to manage all aspects of the cannabis business enterprise, including, increasing, processing, distributing and marketing products.

The challenge argued that the state legislation ran afoul of the 2016 constitutional modification. Lessen courts sided with Florigrown and, in a unusual shift, the Supreme Courtroom ordered two sets of arguments in the case.

But Thursday’s 6-1 choice found that Florigrown, owned in component by prominent Tampa strip-club operator Joe Redner, “has not shown a sizeable likelihood of achievement on the merits of any of its constitutional promises.”


The 2017 law’s requirement that cannabis operators cope with all factors of the cannabis company will involve what is identified as “vertical integration.” In arguing that the need is unconstitutional, Florigrown contended that it limits the range of providers that can take part in the industry.

But the Supreme Court docket reversed a temporary injunction imposed by then-Leon County Circuit Choose Charles Dodson, stating that the vertical-integration prerequisite “is in just the Legislature’s certain authority.”

The court also rejected arguments that the law’s cap on the number of health care-marijuana licenses that the Florida Department of Wellness can situation is opposite to the constitutional modification.

Preceding court rulings that the license restrictions ended up unconstitutional “are primarily based solely on a factual obtaining that the statutory caps have designed medical marijuana unavailable, or insufficiently readily available, in this condition and partly on a authorized conclusion that the statutory caps are unreasonable in light of the amendment’s intent,” the the greater part feeling, shared by Main Justice Charles Canady and Justices John Couriel, Jamie Grosshans, Jorge Labarga, Carlos Muñiz and Ricky Polston, claimed.


“We disapprove of these rulings simply because proficient, substantial evidence does not aid a acquiring that the statute has produced health care cannabis unavailable, and the amendment does not preclude a limit on the amount of MMTCs that can be licensed,” the greater part claimed, utilizing an acronym for clinical cannabis treatment facilities, the time period the condition uses for cannabis operators.

Healthcare cannabis in Florida — the nation’s 3rd most-populous state — has exploded in the couple of quick years due to the fact its legalization. But the business and buyers have been leery about investing or increasing in Florida until finally the Supreme Courtroom fixed the Florigrown circumstance.

“This ruling is welcomed for this market simply because it affirms the regulatory scheme that a great deal of individuals have now built their organization versions around. And for some of the extra modern entrants into the current market, it lets them to ramp up their investing in Florida with self-assurance in the regulatory scheme,” John Lockwood, a lawyer who represents a number of cannabis license holders, advised The News Provider of Florida on Thursday.


But point out Agriculture Commissioner Nikki Fried, a main hashish proponent, blasted the Supreme Court choice, expressing the medical-marijuana industry will “remain shut-off, proscribing independence of chance, weakening the absolutely free industry and main to ever-increased selling prices for clients.”

“This ruling by our Republican-dominated Supreme Courtroom even further entrenches Florida’s unfair, unconstitutional medical cannabis technique set in put by our Republican-dominated Legislature,” Fried, the only statewide elected Democrat, stated in a prepared statement. “This status quo assists completely no one particular apart from the 22 healthcare cannabis companies in Florida at the price of patients.”

Underneath the 2017 legislation, the selection of professional medical marijuana licenses grows as the selection of skilled clients boosts. With far more than 561,000 individuals, at minimum a dozen new licenses are out there. But the Division of Well being has not opened the license application system while the Florigrown lawsuit was awaiting a Supreme  Courtroom ruling.


The Supreme Court docket read arguments in the circumstance final spring, but purchased a new round of arguments centered on no matter if the statute equates to an unconstitutional “special legislation.” The Florida Constitution bars “special” rules, which, frequently, are supposed to benefit unique entities.

During arguments on Oct. 7, Florigrown legal professional Katherine Giddings pointed to the 22 cannabis operators, each and every of which experienced applied for licensure under a 2014 law authorizing non-euphoric hashish, which preceded the passage of the constitutional modification.

“This is certainly a shut class mainly because no a single can at any time acquire the same privileges that these have had,” she mentioned. “This is every thing but a free marketplace. It has developed a monopoly for a couple of entities. That is why the licensing plan is inappropriate and arbitrary.”

But Thursday’s the vast majority belief claimed that “the statute as a whole” does not limit licensure to the candidates that were being granted licenses below the 2014 regulation.


“In addition, any other entity that needs to use for a license in the long run could do so, and may perhaps probably get a person, as the quantity of out there licenses expands … to meet the demands of the point out,” the belief stated. “All potential licensees will receive licenses equivalent to the ones at first issued for the duration of this early phase of Florida’s health-related cannabis industry. The reality that other entities may possibly be part of the class of certified MMTCs in the foreseeable future as circumstances in the point out transform suggests that the class is open and the law basic.”

But in a 10-website page viewpoint that concurred in part and dissented in element with the greater part choice, Justice Alan Lawson disagreed.

A particular regulation violates the Florida Structure if it “grants a privilege to a non-public corporation,” Lawson wrote.

Provisions in the 2017 law “grant specified private corporations — explained so precisely that they may as properly be named in the statute — the proper to MMTC licensure without the need of coming into the levels of competition that others will have to enter for a statutorily capped range of licenses,” Lawson wrote.


“Because the legislation grants this distinct benefit to these private firms, it violates the Florida Structure unless it can be effectively construed as a standard regulation,” he wrote, introducing, “I am informed of no circumstance in which this courtroom has held that a statute making use of a shut class of private entities can be saved from a resolve that it is a distinctive legislation just since the classification plan is realistic in relation to the statute’s purpose.”

Ari Gerstin, a law firm who signifies Florigrown, mentioned in an e mail Thursday that Redner and his staff are  “disappointed with the final decision and are at this time analyzing our options.”

But professional medical cannabis operators at this time in Florida — in which licenses offer for amongst $35 million and $45 million — and companies looking for to build a footprint in the point out celebrated the ruling.

“The very long-awaited decision is properly-reasoned and maintains the position quo, which will support preserve steadiness in the state’s healthcare marijuana market place,” Jim McKee, an lawyer who signifies various operators, explained to the News Service. “We can be expecting an maximize in investment in the Florida health care marijuana current market.”

Copyright 2021 by WJXT Information4Jax – All legal rights reserved.